Pumas 4 Palin

One year later, the Memo still rankles…

Just wanted to update with this video:



This is a follow-up page to Mother of all Memos, what this blog is all about.

By now everyone knows that voters in the Democratic primary season split right down the middle, with Hillary gaining a little more than half the votes cast in the primary season. It is a whole different question as to why she is not the leader in delegate count, why the delegate allocation math is patently absurd, how the system of allocation was gamed. Was the public relations aspect of the political side of the process rigged or stage managed to disadvantage Hillary, were members of the media in on this game? Of course, they were!  It only takes a random sample of any given topic or day’s coverage to show it.

Unfortunately for the party, the reality of ‘fix’,  will never be accepted by Hillary’s enemies. Nor will Hillary’s supporters just ‘get over it’ any time soon. The wounds created early on went too deep with one side being simultaneously just too ingenious in methods and disingenuous in motives. 

This is an election of a generation, with an almost a generational difference in the values, identities, election strategies, and rhetorical methodologies practised by the two camps.

This primary season of the Democrats is a generation-gap in reverse!

This gap is not something that will go away, specially with expressions like “don’t trust anyone below 30”.

Even as Hillary was giving ‘her speech’ and some followers of the other candidate were stubbornly rejecting Hillary with vitriol, and revival of wounds from the past.

The Washington Monthly, carries a regular feature called The Political Animal by Kevin Drum, a popular writer. Guest poster Hilzoy  recently started the dialog off with a quote from the email Hillary sent her supporters, readers took it from there.

What interested us most was how quickly commenters went to the Mother of all Memos as the first inkling of trouble in this campaign. A few pertinent excerpts:

The Washington Monthly
Political Animal by Kevin Drum (Guest Hilzoy),  June 05, 2008
Reader Comments:


Reader junebug (on June 5, 2008 at 12:59 PM)

The memo was stupid & offensive, though not for the reason you’re claiming. The “D-Punjab” reference was a stupid attempt to create a link between Clinton’s work on the Senate India Caucus & the offshoringof American jobs. It was offensive to Clinton, in all fairness, because it’s a gross misrepresentation of her work, but it wasn’t racist.


Reader rk (on June 5, 2008 at 1:29PM)

One of the items used to attack HRC in that memo was titled

” Gupta Said Democrats’    Stand On Outsourcing Was Poll-Year Rhetoric.”

That item refers to a quote by Vinod Gupta in March 2004 regarding policies of the Democratic party (hence the use of Democrats’ rather than Democrat’s) and has little connection to HRC. The item really makes little sense in terms of the outsourcing debate but does introduce the fact that Vinod Gupta had contributed funds to HRC’s senate campaign in 2000.

That bullet point serves only to point out that HRC got campaign contributions from Indian-Americans.

I know that the Obama campaign has used HRC’s joke as their lever for introducing and explaining the memo. That doesn’t change the product or their intent.


Reader Joe (on June 5, 2008 at 3:32 PM)

Obama’s campaign was playing off her own comment to point out her investing in, and receiving money from, Indian companies that took away American jobs. There was absolutely nothing racial about it.


Reader rk (on June 5, 2008 at 4:53 PM)

…. economic nativism aimed at generating animosity toward a specific ethnic group and to anyone perceived to be close to that specific ethnic group is racist. The D-Punjab memo wasn’t directed at outsourcing in general; its sole purpose was to link HRC to India and Indian-Americans (as Joe so ably points out).
One of the bullet points (the investment in India) was related to a company that had nothing to do with outsourcing and was for a business that couldn’t have possibly been performed by Americans (the main business is a chain of bill payment and cell phone recharging shops in India).

The memo isn’t a coherent argument regarding outsourcing. Where it does mention outsourcing no country other than India is mentioned.

The technique of linking a political opponent to a particular ethnic group and implying that such support is unseemly has a long tradition in the United States. Denying that the D-Punjab memo was an example of that technique is just silly.

Reader junebug  (on June 5, 2008 at 7:54PM)

That the memo came into existence at all is due to Obama’s poor judgment on the matter,


Reader Peg  got off the best line of this discussion, in our view (on June 6, 2008 at 8:25PM)

My Republican sister left her party because the religius right took over. I am leaving the Democratic party for much the same reason. Fanatics and cultists have taken charge. Good luck with that.


As we said, the Mother of all Memos keeps on giving.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Stars and Stripes For Ever

Fight Back, Fight For Sarah!

Sarah Palin Legal Defense Fund

Please Contribute Today

Contact Form

I am a Palin Puma

Puams 4 Palin

Follow Sarah On Twitter

RSS Sarah Palin on Facebook

  • Slaying Salmon July 15, 2014
    Home from commercial fishing grounds in Bristol Bay, and here's Piper helping slay salmon to market! A good season for wild reds on the Nushagak, Piper hopes to make enough to cover, maybe, a cell phone bill. Do you agree, as I’ve said before, we need more girls holding up fish in pics instead of holding up iPhones in selfies?!  It’s always wonderful re […]
  • Restoring Honor August 28, 2010
    What an honor it was to speak today at the “Restoring Honor” Rally in D.C. The following is the text of my remarks. You can click here or here to watch a video of it.- Sarah PalinPhoto by Shealah Craighead“Restoring Honor” RallyAugust 28, 2010  Washington, D.C. Thank you so much. Are you not so proud to be an American?What an honor. What an honor.We stand to […]
  • First Leg of the "Good Tidings and Great Joy" Book Tour November 6, 2013
    Looking forward to heading out on the first leg of our "Good Tidings and Great Joy" book tour! I wanted to share with you some of the pre-Thanksgiving schedule and details. (More to come!) We look forward to seeing you on the road, having the opportunity to spread the positive message of this book and really share in the true spirit of the Christma […]
  • It Takes a Village... to Slay a Salmon July 3, 2013
    The beauty of catching some of our Alaskan species with fins is the amount of meat harvested with each fish. Rod and reeling red salmon, or, my favorite, a big (or even not so big) halibut ensures you've got a few dinners taken care of even when feeding a bunch of people.We had a blast hauling in halibut in Homer a few days ago, despite the cold rain an […]
  • Commemorating the 150th Anniversary of Gettysburg June 30, 2013
    Today marks the beginning of the week-long ceremonies commemorating the 150th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg. There will be a full re-enactment of the battle, discussions with panels of historians, and of course a re-reading of the Gettysburg Address. But as Lincoln affirmed when he dedicated that hallowed ground, nothing we say or do can “add or de […]
  • #SOTUGottaBKiddingMe February 13, 2013
    If you missed President Obama’s State of the Union address last night, you didn’t miss much – especially if you watched any of his past four State of the Union addresses. We heard the same recycled rhetoric, and we heard his Orwellian declaration that the cornucopia of new federal programs he proposed, as well as his intention to eradicate world poverty, wou […]
  • New Year's Resolution to Keep the Faith! January 1, 2013
    Best wishes to everyone for a happy New Year! In the coming days there will be a great deal of debate about the goings-on in the political arena and the shenanigans in Washington. Constitutional commonsense conservatives must stay engaged and hold our “leaders” accountable to the voice of average everyday hard working Americans or we will very soon become an […]

Pumas Heart Palin

RSS Conservatives 4 Palin

RSS Governor Palin 4 President

New Badge of Outrage

RSS NEWS-BUSTERS! Don’t Believe What You Read Elsewhere!

  • MSNBC: Donald Trump Doesn’t Like CNN's Don Lemon Because He's Black December 11, 2017
    On Monday’s Morning Joe, New York Times Chief White House Correspondent Peter Baker was welcomed onto the panel to discuss his and his colleagues’ latest report about President Trump’s TV news-watching habits. In the course of discussing the piece, MSNBC National Affairs Analyst John Heilemann made a point of bringing up how Trump’s favorite nightly news sho […]
    Chris Reeves
  • NBC Touts Left-Wing Activist Demanding Defeat of GOP Tax Bill December 11, 2017
    While covering President Trump making a “final pitch” for the Republican tax bill, on Monday’s NBC Today, correspondent Peter Alexander declared that the legislative push came “despite criticism it benefits the wealthy more than the middle class.” He even promoted a social media video of a Democratic Party activist calling on Republicans to reject the plan. […]
    Kyle Drennen
  • Amid NYC Terror Coverage MSNBC Panel Complains About Guns in America, Trump December 11, 2017
    As information was still coming in regarding Monday’s attempted terror attack in the New York City subway, an MSNBC panel discussing the news ridiculously shifted the topic to outrage over guns and gun crime in the U.S. And on top of that, they bemoaned how President Trump would try to make the attack an immigration issue to support his temporary travel ban. […]
    Nicholas Fondacaro
  • NBC Dismisses Media Screw Ups, Attacks Trump Instead December 11, 2017
    On Monday’s NBC Today, correspondent Peter Alexander briefly noted that “the President ratchets up his war on the news media” with tweets criticizing liberal press for a recent series of high-profile mistakes and fake news stories. However, the reporter was more interested in turning the topic into an excuse to slam Trump for his own “misleading claims.” […]
    Kyle Drennen
  • 40 Minutes After NYC Terror Attack, CNN Obsesses Over Trump’s Diet Coke Habits December 11, 2017
    An unfolding terrorist attack in New York City wasn’t enough to derail CNN’s obsession with Donald Trump. Forty minutes after suicide bomber Akayed Ullah on Monday attempted to murder people with a bomb, New Day journalists lost interest. Co-host Alisyn Camerota had more important topics: Trump’s appreciation of Diet Coke. 
    Scott Whitlock

RSS Larry Johnson Gives Lying No Quarter!

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Country Before Party

Crack the Acorn for Truth

A World Wide Blog

Live Traffic Watch

Back Posts

%d bloggers like this: